joannejacobs.net
« Winter is upon us! | Main | Episode 3: The Verdict »

May 15, 2005

Star Wars and the Land of Might-Have-Been

In the extended entry I explore the reasons why this last Star Wars film means so much to my generation.

It’s probably hard for many people to understand just how much of an influence Star Wars has had in the lives of people around my age. When the first Star Wars film came out, I was just six years old; old enough to absorb the details and nuances of a grown-up film, but also young enough to be completely enthralled, entranced and enraptured in this wonderful world of a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. It was for me, a faerytale, and I was still at the age of being read faerytales. I still believed in Santa Claus. I dreamt of princesses and far off kingdoms. So the world of Star Wars was as much a part of my childhood and my vision of the Land of Might-Have-Been as any other morality play, or bedtime story.

But unlike the Grimm faerytales and the bible stories that children were read, there was light and colour and sound in which to be utterly immersed. It’s so hard to explain to people only a few years younger than myself how revolutionary that film was for its time. The special effects were absolutely the best we had ever seen. The sound was almost beyond belief. The fact that it shook the seats and the floor of the cinema was something we had never before experienced. The colours, the costumes and the ideas were not so completely alien as to leave us out of our depth, but still we all felt we were part of something extraordinary.

As the years past, and the second film was released, The Empire Strikes Back, all the familiar faces were there, but yet there was still something new: this time, our hearts were torn from us, and we had more questions than answers. We were left with a film that was as thrilling as the first, but which taught us that uncomplicated happy endings can never be assumed. As an impressionable then nine year old, Empire left its mark in my life as a “coming of age” story, dealing out both victory and defeat at once.

Finally, as a girl of twelve, on the cusp of my teenage years, Return of the Jedi was released, and my faerytale was brought to life again in a way that resolved the issues of the second film, but also dealt sympathetically with the issue of falling from grace. Generally the faith of our generation was restored in the “way of things”, but we were more aware that the difference between good and evil was perhaps not so clear as we had been led to believe. Rather than being a simple matter of discerning black from white, it was more likely that the search for truth and peace would be through fields of grey.

I believe this progression from faerytale to adult tale of loss and gain is part of the reason why my generation feel so very close to Star Wars. When you think of how it shaped and echoed our own personal development, you can see just how important it became to our culture. That’s why there was such a revolt when the first of the prequels (The Phantom Menace) failed to deliver anything that would impact on our lives in so profound a fashion. That’s why as adults we looked on the love story of Anakin and Padme (in Attack of the Clones) with a deep sense of cynicism and lost hope. We left the theatre glad to have more of the story, but without the almost religious experience of reflecting on our own lives.

Revenge of the Sith opens at midnight on Wednesday night and I will be there, holding on to the hope that this last of the six films will fulfil the expectations of my generation. We are a deeply cynical lot, and we feel the need to be exposed to the best and the worst of ourselves. Rather than turning from the dark side, we seek to gaze into the abyss, to face our weaknesses and even to give in to them. Because it’s only through understanding the depth of our own darkness that we can find something good in ourselves. It’s only when we absorb the obscure political, philosophical and emotional factors impacting upon our lives that we can truly begin to see a path for our own redemption.

Ivor Novello once wrote a most magnificent ballad about losing hope, and then gaining it again. I’ve included the entire ballad below, because I think it articulates so well the cynicism followed by the dawn of hope that pervades both the psyche of our generation, and premise of the Star Wars universe.

Somewhere there's another land
Different from this world below.
Far more mercifully planned
Than the cruel place we know.
Innocence and peace are there.
All is good that is desired.
Faces there are always fair.
Love grows never old nor tired.

We shall never find that lovely land of Might-Have-Been.
I shall never be your king nor you shall be my queen.
Days may pass and years may pass and seas lie in between.
We shall never find that lovely land of Might-Have-Been.

Sometimes on the rarest nights
Comes the vision calm and clear,
Gleaming with unearthly lights
On my path of doubt and fear.
Winds from that far land are blown,
Whispering with secret breath.
Hope that plays her tune alone.
Love that conquers pain and death.


Shall we ever find that lovely land of Might-Have-Been?
Will I ever be your king or you at last my queen?
Days may pass or years may pass, the seas may lie between.
Shall we ever find our lovely land of Might-Have-Been?

I’m hopeful this last of the Star Wars sextet will provide that opportunity to find hope in ourselves, so that our generation can go back to the original films of our childhood, and believe again in the Land of Might-Have-Been.

Posted by jj at May 15, 2005 5:47 PM

Comments. Please PREVIEW your comment before submitting. This helps the server to save your entry.

Great memories beautifully articulated JJ.

As an 8 year old I remember my Star Wars experience vividly. Awe inspiring. Before Star Wars came along all the 'pictures' meant to me was HR Puff'N'Stuff and the Banana Splits on a Saturday afternoon.

However my fairy tale romance with Star Wars was interrupted when as a 10 year old I snuck in to experience the next big sci-fi move which came along ... only to have the sight of the Alien exploding through Kanes rib cage burned into my memory ... courtesy of Ridley Scott's Alien!

Still, I hope they have found a role for my favourite Star Wars character ... Jabba da Hut ... a truly innovative entrepreneur! ;-)

I look forward to your post-Sith analysis.

H

Posted by: H at May 16, 2005 11:59 PM

Well said! Never thought of Ep 1 that way. Heard great things about Ep 3. I'll be Gold Classing that one Thursday afternoon, should be fantastic! (if I don't hit the bar too much prior to screening!)

Posted by: Billy at May 17, 2005 10:41 PM

Here's a question I'd like to see analysed... in light of Palpatine's behaviour (I read the book before I saw the movie), the way he finally turns Skywalker and the "changes" discussed in the last of the most recent series of New Jedi Order books... can anybody delineate, compare and contrast the two supposed sides of the Force?

Without, that is, saying that these are the Good Guys and those are the Bad Guys? I might have a theory, but I'd very much like to know what other SW fans are thinking...

Posted by: P at May 18, 2005 6:03 PM

Very interesting read, because I'm from a generation for whom Star Wars also means so much, but for different reasons!

I was an early teenage science fiction fan when I saw Star Wars. At that time, this meant reading a lot of books, because books were far superior to TV or film. Take Dr Who as an example. Much as I loved it then, and am happily watching the repeats on ABC now, the effects are, well, just not convincing. With one or two exceptions, like 2001 and Planet of the Apes, watching science fiction on TV or film before Star Wars meant turning a blind eye to the, literally, rubbery bits. Yes, you could fill in with your imagination, and enjoy the stories anyway, but you couldn't really immerse yourself when so much of the world was obviously fake.

Then came Star Wars. I'll never forget that giant Imperial Destroyer booming overhead in the opening scene. Everything looked convincing, and everyone just fitted naturally into the environment as if they lived there all the time, not just for the movie. No featureless tiny smooth spaceship models, no ridiculous vinyl clothes. It was REAL.

Plus, it's a beautifully told story. (Try running a stopwatch during the final Death Star attack on the rebel base to see how skilfully Lucas manipulates the timing.) The dialogue is not inspired but mercifully free of technobabble, and the actors are good.

Star Wars was so brilliantly convincing that we all overlooked the fact that it's hardly science fiction at all! As JJ says, it's a faerytale, complete with rescued princess, wizards, and swordplay. Which doesn't stop me from still enjoying it, just that these days I consider it my favourite fantasy film.

Empire Strikes Back came out in our late teens, and we enjoyed it because it was a natural development and step forward, from Star Wars. The characters became more rounded and interesting, the dialogue was much better, and the story more complex. We'd grown used to realistic believable science fiction worlds since the release of Star Wars, and appreciated that Lucas wasn't relying on just effects to impress us.

All of which set us up for the disappointment of Return of the Jedi. It's for the most part a kiddie movie, exemplified by the Ewoks. To my generation, now adults when it came out, Return of the Jedi was a condescending exercise in selling merchandise. We lost our sense of wonder with that movie.


Posted by: Hugh at May 20, 2005 12:53 PM

Post a comment

Please PREVIEW posts before submitting. This helps my host server to save your comments.




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)